This was Abby's first out right lie.
I was somewhat disappointed but mostly I just found this hilarious.
Me: Abby, who ate the chocolate bar?
Abby: Hannah did it. She took it down stairs and ate it all.
Me: "If Hannah ate it, why are you the one with brown stuff all around your mouth and chocolate on your breathe?
Abby: Hannah made me eat it. I didn't want to, but she made me!
Since that was an inconceivable answer, even Abby knew she was cooked and quickly confessed.
I don't think I need to worry about her becoming a poker player or a politician. :)